An 11-year-old girl stops eating but remains miraculously alive and well. A nurse sent to investigate whether she is a fraud meets a journalist hungry for a story.
Set in the Irish Midlands in the 1850s, Emma Donoghue's The Wonder - inspired by numerous European and North American cases of 'fasting girls' between the 16th century and the 20th - is a psychological thriller about a child's murder threatening to happen in slow motion before our eyes. Pitting all the seductions of fundamentalism against sense and love, it is a searing examination of what nourishes us, body and soul.
©2016 Emma Donaghue (P)2016 Macmillan Digital Audio
Excited to listen to this book after the brilliance of 'Room', but was disappointed. The 'Irish' accents were often inaudible or too thick to understand at all and often in places where it was important to the story line. But the basic premise was interesting so I plodded on to the too-tidy end.
On twitter I described this as the most painful audiobook I've ever listened too and really that isn't far from the truth. The tag line should be 'British women butchers Irish accents in a way that's frankly offensive'. The way should does the Irish characters accents makes them come off as the most ill educated, naive idiots the world ever laid eyes on. Not one Irish person's accent was accurate. Also in 1850s Ireland not all Irish people in Athlone would've spoken fluent English.
The story seems fairly decent and I may stick the print copy on hold at the library but don't put yourself through this monstrosity its not worth it.
Also audiobook producers there are 5 million Irish people out there, could you not have asked one of them to work in tandem with Kate Lock and do the Irish accents? Seriously, the Irish have had their culture erased for long enough!
Story twists and turns drew me in. as an Irish listener, found Kate Lock's Irish accents occasionally a bit too heavy on the Leprechaun so became a bit of a distraction.
I continued to think that I had heard this story before but this must be because it is an event that keeps occurring throughout the world in many cultures/religions. I was in turn horrified, puzzled, but mostly furiously indignant. The narrator was wonderful with so many accents and she voiced the girl with such sympathy. What a wonderful writer. I expect, like myself many people tried this book after having loved Room. This is different but still a kidnapping in effect.
Yes, a very atmospheric book, which throws into light questions about religion, faith amongst so many other things. Delightful depiction of the girl.
Lib - I really disliked her at the beginning, but she grew on me the more I listened. A very conflicted and complicated character.
Lib again, I think. The Irish accents seem quite false to begin with, but I got used to them and I found them quite charming in the end!
An young girl hasn't eaten for four months - can a Nightingale nurse discover the truth before it's too late?
This is a brilliant mystery that kept me guessing until the end - highly recommend it!
Kildonan by the sea
An exploration of belief and faith exposed to the abrasive demands of reality and methodical scrutiny, a study of how we arrange what we want to believe through the power of imagination and religious guilt and fear. A celebration of love and rational thought defeating dogma with intelligence and imagination.
A beautifully written book that is intelligent and hopeful, while holding the reader in suspense till the very end. The characters are crisp and clearly drawn, the plot opens and develops with every turn of the page, making the drama of this people's lives real and concerning.
A lovely find that surprised me as much as it pleased.
I've never read a book written in such a unique style. Having previously lived in Ireland for several years, and was a care assistant their too. I could vividly see the land scape and the people pictured by the author. I too was an English outsider entering private worlds of amazing people and experiencing a totally different way of life which I felt privileged. I can see those unique small homes, the peat bogs and the very very heavy smell of peat burning to heat homes.
The story was gripping, I held my breath as the nurse ebbed her steps further and further.
The story was so cleverly written, a very talented writer.
I listened to this book via Audible. The narrator made this story totally come to life, added to all the emotional energy of the book. I'm so very glad I experience the book that way as she dressed the characters and made them come to life in front of me.
An excellent book for a book group to enjoy and discuss as the characters are so rich and variable.
"Moving story about love and life"
Probably, I have already read the book:)
Irish accent, Anna's intonation and voice
When Lib talked about her daughter
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.