Rosanna Menici is just a girl when she meets Roberto Rossini, the man who will change her life. In the years to come, their destinies are bound together by their extraordinary talents as opera singers and by their enduring but obsessive love for each other - a love that will ultimately affect the lives of those closest to them. For, as Rosanna slowly discovers, their unison is haunted by irreversible events from the past.
©2014 Lucinda Riley (P)2014 W. F. Howes Ltd
"A tale of passion and betrayal from bestselling author, (Lucinda Riley)
"Atmospheric, heart-rending and multi-layered" ( Grazia) on (The Girl on the Cliff)
This is a fun book, interesting story and well narrated when the narrator speak in her normal voice. However when she does these awful Italian accents one is so distracted that you lose touch with the story. I do not understand why this is necessary. When one reads all the wonderful swedish novels the narrators use their normal voices and no one tries to do fake Swedish accents. This should be the same!
My advice buy the book or kindle version and skip the audio version. A shame because the narrator is fine for English!
This story is set in Italy, written in the first person and read completely unnecessarily in a forced Italian accent. We do not need our books 'acted out' or interpreted or coloured in by the reader, Audible! And we especially do not need them acted/interpreted/coloured using an accent unnatural to the reader. We just need them to be read well in a way that allows us to connect with the author and her/his story. I couldn't bare to listen to enough of this to get any sense of the story at all and have returned it.
Yes, provided it is read by a different reader.
No forced 'italian' accent, no over-emoting, just read in a way that does not get in the way of the story and the author.
not one narrated by Eva Alexander
Didn't finish it because of the narration
I love most of Lucinda Riley's books but the narrator's appalling attempt at character variation, especially the poor Italian accent made this book a miserable experience
As always, I was sorry when this book came to an end. I have only been reading fiction for around 18 months and Lucinda Riley is by far my favourite author to-date.. Her stories are so compelling; the listener is drawn into the lives of the characters very quickly - the way the author weaves around the different time zones is brilliant - it's as if you step into the story right away - I noted the original story here was written under the author's earlier pen name and updated ...........please, please Lucinda hurry up and update your earlier books; I am now bereft as I am at the point where I have listened to all your books currently available via audio! Cannot wait to see another appear in the list. I highly recommend this author. I mustn't forget the narrator here - Eva Alexander - who was brilliant and made it all come alive.
This is definitely one of the best of this genre I've heard, totally compelling and I hated turning it off.
I loved this story, the narrator drew me in with her voice and I found myself listening to it long after I meant to turn off to do something else. The characters were well written and I felt empathy for the main character Rosanna although I did get annoyed with her at times which shows how much I got into the story.
rosanna met Roberto when she was eleven years old and knew at that moment she loved him and would one day marry him. he knew she had the makings of a great opera star.
the main story is of course centred around rosanna and Roberto but it is the story of luca's, rosanna's brother, life which runs alongside which was the one that brought tears to my eyes at the end.
well written by Lucinda riley and performed by eva alexander who brought the story to life.
Beautiful, unique, heart-breaking
Rosana - main character - an interesting heroine - brave but fragile
It was the most beautifully read book! I have no idea why there are so many bad reviews about the narrator that almost put me off listening to this book - by far by favourite - her voice was perfectly matched to the main character and she made this book so much more special
The love affair that will break your heart
It's a beautiful, unique story that takes you on an adventure - full of surprises, bitter-sweet moments and will leave you wanting to get lost in its world for as long as possible
My favourite of the 4 Lucinda Riley books I have read so far. Set in the opera world in Italy and the Cotswolds. The book was beautifully narrated by Eva Alexander, bringing the characters to life.
I didn't want it to end, feel like I have lost some friends!
There are some interesting twists and turns an I enjoyed the book to the end. Worth the effort in my opinion.
Someone who believes that one must sacrifice love and marriage to be an excellent, loving and devoted mother. Someone who doesn't care that very smart men and women make truly idiotic and incomprehensible choices. Someone who isn't offended by a story which demeans humans by believing they make choices as foolish and negative as the choices made by these characters.
Yes. I've truly enjoyed "The Lavener Garden", "The Midnight Rose" and "The Orchid House". These works by Ms. Riley were outstanding and inspiring and excellent.
Anger and Disappointment.
Ms. Riley's decision to have Rossana choose loneliness rather than the strength to make the relationship work, was so demeaning of a woman's ability to adapt and change priorities as needed and as necessary. Too degrade her choice to accompany her husband when it could have been that Nico had no more than a slight cold, was mean and wrong to the complexity of human relationships. Sometimes women/men need to choose their spouse and sometimes their children and sometimes the consequences are not anyone's "fault". Also hated Lucas decision not to return to England to look for Abbie after he made the choice to leave the church because she had not responded to his post cards? What was that??? Difficult to admire Abbie's patience. Also, Abbie's decision to hide the birth of her child from her best friend and the child's Aunt? So many stupid choices and decisions. And also, Roberto's failure to reveal his parentage to his child and to ask her to keep the truth from Rossana in order to avoid hurting her? This could have happened and would have made sense and would have given Ella the opportunity to know and love her father, in that capacity, before his death. I would never recommend this book. Really made me angry.
"Captivating and endearing"
I loved this story. At the end my tears spilled and I was so grateful to have spent time with the characters. Moving and reflective. To top it off the narrator was exceptional.
"I hate faux, phoney accents!"
An actual interesting storyline, interesting characters, and a narrator who woesn't do a faux Italian accent. It sounds fake, and it is annoying to listen to.
That there were no interesting characters or storyline whatsoever. I have enjoyed her other books, and were looking forward to reading this, but this doesn't come even halfway close to her other books.
She had a horrible fake Italian accent whenever one of the characters in the book said something. I don't even know why narrators do this. Everyone can hear that they don't know the language they are trying to fake, and we know that the characters are from Italy. Wouldn't they speak Italin to each other then? Why the need for bad accents?
No, I'm sorry but it didn't!
A beautifully woven story of love & passion in relationships as well as vocations. I listen to 2-4 books a week, so at least 100 a year. I only have one more Lucinda Riley book to read & will then have read or listened to all she's written to date. I've enjoyed them all. She has insight into relationships that give depth and authenticity to sometimes complex characterizations. Roberto is the one you love to hate, but he's just sympathetic enough to understand Rosanna's love for him. I think my favorite character was Luca though...loving & selfless was so happy for his HEA.
Beautifully written, the author keeps you so engrossed in the story. Great read. I highly recommend this book, thoroughly enjoyed it.
"another enjoyable 'chick-lit'"
I enjoyed this story. I could not stand the narrator when she used her "faux" accents. At times she would also speed up her reading for no apparent reason. Had she just read in her normal voice instead of "trying" to use phony accents & deeper voices, the whole listen would have been far more enjoyable, but....instead it was really annoying and spoiled much of the listening experience.
Absolutely wonderful book once again from mrs Riley!
Writing is the form of art I admire the most , as it requires an imagination beyond average... and authors like her have my upmost respect.
My desperation comes from the act that I have just listened to all her books on audible and don't know what to read next... the narrator was also wonderful...
"What a great read!"
This is by far the best Lucinda Riley book I have listened to - you will not be disappointed.
"The only this missing was a soundtrack!"
Beautiful, and it made me want to listen to some opera, especially La Boheme. The writing was so rich, I kept expecting the characters to break into song!
the store was great and I enjoyed it however the narrator accents were so bad that they were distracting and really lowered the pleasure of listening to this book
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.