©1981 by Ellis Peters; (P)1998 by Blackstone Audiobooks
"Each addition to the series is a joy. Long may the Chronicles continue." (USA Today)
Yes...it is a good Ellis Peter story...well written and interesting.
Totally! Her ludicrously bad attempt at a Welsh accent for Cadfael was so irritating and jarring that it spoiled the experience for me. It would have been better if she had not tried...I am amazed that the producers accepted it. Rather than being absorbed by the story I was constantly being wrenched into the present whenever Cadfael spoke!
This is the fifth in the absorbing and highly aclaimed Cadfael series and shows author Ellis Peters at her best. With deeply sympothetic characters, vivid descriptions and a fantastic twist, this is a great listen from start to finish.
I like the plots and historical setting of the Cadfael stories, but this version is completely ruined by the narration. Joanna Ward's accents are laughably bad, with her Welsh resembling the clipped syllables from the Indian subcontinent, while Shropshire swerves between Somerset and Cockney. Seriously, listen for a moment and you'll think Brother Cadfael is from Pakistan. On top of that, it's hard to tell when she's doing a character's voice or a description, as she delivers in a monotone with little variation in pace or pitch. They must have scoured the land to find an actress who can't do a Welsh accent ... or indeed act.
I loved the story but have already read it several times so I knew I would. BUT for the first time ever with an Audible book I was very disappointed with the reader. Stephen Thorne has read all the other Cadfael book I have listened to and I really feel it needs a male voice. More disappointingly she was particularly bad at the required accent for a Welshman and she, like so many people , think all country folk speak with the "oh ar" accent that dreadful TV peasants use. I am a proud Salopian born and bred here and know no one who speaks like that. If readers are unable to genuine local accents they should not try to differentiate Te voices but just use expression and emotion to read the different voices. I am also disappointment when people make no effort to find out. The proper pronunciation of place names which is probably the producer or directors job, not the reader .
very well crafted
Spoilers - the reveal at the end of who the leper was, which if am honest I had suspected, but the way it all comes out was very well done.
She carries the charaters well, th
Not really, but it wouldn't hurt it
Very good story.
Love the whole series! Engaging listening. Adequately well read. Personally prefer a male narrator for these, but that's just a slight preference.
"The Leper of Saint Giles"
Good. Moderately enteraining.
"Another great listen!"
I have been slowly going through the BC series, and have enjoyed them all thus far. But I want to comment specifically on the reader, Joanna Ward. There have been some comments on this, and other BC books, about her being a bad choice. I have to strongly disagree. Of the readers I have heard so far, she is clearly the top one. Her ability to add Welsh inflections, where needed, are terrific, and her male/female character voices are as good as anybody else's given that any reader, male or female, is going to be challenged to sound authentic doing the "other sex".
I have just started "Virgin in the Ice", and the reader (Vanessa Benjamin, I believe) is already bothering me immensely.
I wish that Joanna Ward had read them all.
"Another well written Brother Cadfael mystery"
Well written story; well told
While the plot is good; the enjoyment for me is in the telling.
Like many peiople I
The whole series gives a wonderful picture of 14th century England. It is also provides a peep into customs, religion and the basics of forensics and criminal psychology. Reading in chronological order provides a good insight into a civil war not often written about.
"Why was this narrator chosen?"
I have read all of the Brother Cadfael books in French as well as English, and am a solid fan of this author and series.
While I enjoyed the accent of this narrator, however, and her skill, her efforts to convey male voices failed in my view (as a function of her voice capabilities), with the unfortunate and unintended consequence of making all of these characters (and almost all characters are male of course) sound pompous and self-important. I have much preferred male narrators for this series.
"No mystery at all"
Well-narrated, but this murder was no mystery at all. I really dislike books peopled by caricatures rather than characters, who do stupid things merely to advance the plot. Ellis Peters is no grand master of crime.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.