I have liked all of Macbrides books and this is no exception. He never disappoints. I was unsure because it was not about his usual Aberdonian characters but it was a great read, gritty and real with unexpected twists to the story line. And the narrator was spot on.

I haven't read any of this author's books before so was not sure what I expected. The plot had sounded interesting but as the plot focused so much on the main character which I just couldn't like I did not enjoy it. There was much to much violence by the "good guys".

I've read most of Martina Coles books and so must enjoy this type of "read". I couln't stop listening and enjoyed every moment of Birthdays for the Dead. The Characters were colourful and I found myself tranported as the story unfolded. I had no idea "who dunnit" another bonus. Really enjoyed both the story and the narator.

I have read or listened to all of Mr MacBride's previous offerings and this is the most graphic (gratuitously so) to date. I physically squirmed and pulled faces of distaste, disbelief and horror whilst listening. Most unpleasant - please go back to DS McRae and your thoroughly enjoyable Tartan Noir.