The narrators voice is incredibly annoying, not enough emotion in her voice at all. Very flat and grating. Such a shame as there is over 10hours of her talking but I'm not sure if I can listen to the whole book!! Great story ruined by the narrator who puts no passion into her narrating. Such a shame, very disappointed.
I never did understand the need to squeeze book (or any other media or art form) into genres such as 'Young Adult' or 'Teen'. I am 48 years old and thoroughly enjoyed the Harry Potter series. A such is the same for The Hunger Games. A well written (and in this case narrated) book I have just finished Part 1 of the Audio Book and am looking forward to the second part.
Mother of 3, bookworm from birth & audiobook addict from the age of 5yrs.
I love this trilogy and have collected the books in all formats, paperback, kindle e-book & audio, as well as having the film on blu-ray.
Covering a wide variety of social, economical & political issues, as well as having the added edge of believability in this age of reality television, The Hunger Games has me hooked from beginning to end no matter what format i use. (i have the series in paperback, kindle e-books & audible audiobook)
The writing itself is gripping, engaging and fast paced and the narration flows very well.
The characters are well rounded and the relationships between them are strong and well developed.
I have been listening to audiobooks from a very young age and although i have my old favourites that have grown up with me as well as some new favourites, this series definitely ranks in my top 5 listens.
I am fairly new to dystopian fiction and haven’t read many in books in this genre but i have compared this trilogy to my other favourite dystopian trilogy, Divergent by Veronica Roth.
I am huge fan of the 'Young Adult' genre, although the genre title always amuses me as you couldn't find another category that spans a much wider customer base than the title suggests.
From Harry Potter to Twilight, Narnia to Divergent this series holds its own in a very competitive genre and will be a firm favourite with readers of all ages.
It was the publicity surrounding the release of the DVD that got me interested in listening to this book, What a great decision that was, the book is very well read and had me gripped from the moment it began.
I sped through the story in a couple of days, it was a truely captivating with the characters coming alive in the mind.
The story of poverty and oppression has been done before but this seemed so refreshing to have it done so well, I am really looking forward to the second and third books that I also have downloaded from Audible.
Today I watched the DVD and whilst it was enjoyable it did not do the book justice.
But this is a review of the book and as such it is a 5 star cracker of a story.
I enjoyed the story but didn't like the reader. Very unconvincing when she had to do male voices. Also a lot of mispronounciation even allowing for the differences in American and English. Would have been better to have had several readers. Am not going to listen to the sequels for this reason. Have bought them on Kindle.
This is a fantastic story, full of drama, action and excitement, as well as a very well written main character who you instantly become attached to, despite her prickly personality. The book is clearly read, although the woman's voice was difficult to listen to, to begin with. She is quite robotic and doesn't inject much life into the characters, she sometimes misjudges the tone or idea behind some of the speech. However you soon get so wrapped up in the story that you forget about this and it only becomes a minor irritant every now and again!
Firstly let me comment on the story and then I will move on to the real crux of my review, the narration.
I was persuaded by various friend that "no, Hunger Games isn't a children's book it is really good" and "It makes some really good points about politics and stuff". So let me clear this up. Hunger Games absolutely is a children's book and that is no bad thing. I found much of it, especially the politics and characterization, clunky and obvious but that is my own fault as a 40 year old man for listening to young adult fiction. I can easily see how the story and it's heroine would appeal to a younger audience with less jaded and sophisticated tastes.
So I don't want to focus on the simplistic and implausible World Collins has created nor the one dimensional nature of all the character who are simply there to fit one narrative purpose rather than plausible figures to understood and engaged with. The book is fine for what it is but doesn't have the appeal to a grown up audience of say, Philip Pullman.
What is not fine is the narration. As a fan of Star Trek, TNG, I was amused to note that Caroline McCormick was the actress who played the minor role of Minuet in the TV series. The role was basically a hologram with whom one of the characters fall in love. I had assumed at the time that the flimsy nature of the character was intentional as reflecting that she was the creation of a holodeck not a real person with real feelings. Having listened to Carolyn McCormick's narration of these books I am forced to assume that Minuet was the absolute limit of her acting abilities and she is simply incapable of imparting the emotional depth of a sun dried puddle to her performances.
Her reading of this book is truly extraordinary in it's awfulness. Very nearly enough to make me give up on the book altogether. Her attempts to portray different characters are risible and she barely seems to understand the text she is reading - and this is not a complex text after all. It was of no surprise to me to learn, on consulting IMDB, that Minuet still marks a career high water mark for McCormick even thirty years on.
So, in summary, Hunger Games is a perfectly passable kids book but not one that any self-respecting adult should be recommending to their peers. That, however, should be moot since the narration makes the whole experience traumatic for the listener.
I am a long haul truck driver so have lots of time to listen to audio books. I am a sci fi fan and look for books with original ideas.
This was the best book I have listened to in a year (and I listen to a lot). The scenario was well described and story moved along at a sharp pace. The plot was unpredictable and interesting. Recommended.